Markets, Mystics & Mayhem podcast: Ep8

Published on 30 October 2024

In episode eight, we take a look at the growing divergence between the Aussie and Kiwi economies. The root cause? Monetary policy. The RBA and RBNZ took very different strategies post-Covid. But first, we share our takeaways from a recent speech by RBNZ Governor Adrian Orr. The RBNZ was among the first and most aggressive central banks in hiking interest rates, post-Covid. But in his speech, Orr signalled that they can be “more incremental” on the way down. But the question is, how incremental is incremental? We break it down.

How does Aotearoa compare to Australia?

MMM_ep8

The RBNZ was very aggressive in their tightening of monetary policy, following the surge in inflation as we broke out of Covid. The RBNZ was the first major central bank to start hiking in late 2021. They started off with a few 25bp hikes, and then they delivered seven 50bps moves with one 75bp hike for good measure. The cash rate was catapulted from just 0.25%, to 5.5%. It was the hardest and fastest tightening cycle we’ve seen.

But in a recent speech, Governor Adrian Orr said “On the way down we can be more incremental, and we have been… We’re being more incremental because we’re in calmer waters but also because of that lingering inflation persistence on the domestic side.”

To us, “incremental” means a more measured pace of cuts on the way to neutral (2.75%). We think the RBNZ will deliver another 50bp move in November (to 4.25%), and they can easily justify another 50bp cut in February (to 3.75%). Cutting from 5.5% to 3.75% makes policy much less restrictive. But it will still be restrictive, and “will remain [restrictive] over the coming quarters as we get more and more confident that pricing behaviour has renormalized,” (Governor Adrian Orr). The RBNZ needs to get the cash rate below 4% ASAP. And then they can cut in 25bp increments in a search for a neutral setting.

In the episode, we also discuss the growing divergence between the Aussie and Kiwi economy. And the root cause is the different monetary policy strategies taken post-Covid. The RBNZ took a hard and fast approach. It’s resulted in a sharper slowdown in economic activity, climbing unemployment, but a faster fall in inflation. The RBA, in stark contrast, went slow and steady to preserve employment gains. Less aggressive tightening has led to a more resilient economy and labour market in Australia, but a slower easing in inflation.